How to Choose a Short-Term Rental Manager
A short-term rental manager can save you hours a week, or quietly cost you more than it earns. This guide covers the questions that matter when you compare managers: how they charge, what the fee really covers, how you can leave, and what you should see on your statement. It is general information, not legal or tax advice.
1. Full-service, co-hosting or listing-only
Companies use these words differently, so read each one's own description. Broadly:
- Full-service management. The manager runs the listing, pricing, guest messages, cleaning and turnovers, maintenance calls and owner reporting. You approve big repairs and get a statement and a payout.
- Co-hosting. The manager works inside your existing Airbnb or Vrbo account, usually handling guests and pricing, while you keep some tasks (often cleaning crews or maintenance). Fees are usually lower, and so is the workload the manager takes on.
- Listing or revenue-only services. Some companies offer only listing optimization and pricing, alongside a co-host or cleaner you already have. In this directory, for example, Leveled MGMT describes a "Listing Ops" tier and One Fine BnB a "Partner" tier for owners with their own cleaning and maintenance team.
- Traditional cabin and beach rental agencies. In markets like the Smoky Mountains, Myrtle Beach and the Outer Banks, long-running local agencies often run their own booking sites, front desks, housekeeping and maintenance, and pay owners a split of rental revenue.
2. How managers charge
Most managers charge a percentage, but the number alone doesn't tell you much. The important question is what the percentage is taken from.
- Percentage of revenue. Usually stated as a percentage of "gross booking revenue," "nightly revenue," "base rent" or the "nightly rate." These are not the same thing: some include cleaning and pet fees in the base, and some exclude taxes, platform fees or guest fees. Ask for a worked example.
- Revenue split. Common with cabin and beach agencies, written as an owner/manager split (for example, RE/MAX Cove Mountain publishes splits "from a 60/40 split up to 80/20 split").
- Tiered or portfolio pricing. Some companies lower the rate as you add homes, or charge more for homes expected to earn less (see Boost Rentals and STR Management).
- Add-on fees. Look for monthly technology fees, onboarding or setup fees, linen programs, credit card processing, maintenance markups, hot tub or pool service, supply restocking and tax-filing fees. For example, RPI Vacation Rentals publishes a monthly technology fee, and Rest Easy Nashville a monthly tax-remittance fee.
- Cleaning fees. Turnover cleaning is often charged to the guest and paid to the cleaner, separately from the management fee. Ask who keeps any difference.
66 of the 440 companies in this directory publish a management fee. Each one is quoted word for word on its profile and on its market page, with a link to the source. A published rate is a starting point, not a quote for your home.
3. What is (and isn't) included
Ask for the list in writing. Typical items to confirm:
- Professional photos and listing setup
- Pricing and revenue management (and how often rates are reviewed)
- Which booking channels your home appears on, and whether the manager's own direct-booking site is one of them
- Guest screening, messaging and 24/7 emergency response
- Housekeeping, laundry and linens, and who supplies them
- Inspections between stays
- Routine maintenance vs. billed repairs, and any markup on vendor invoices
- Consumables (paper goods, toiletries, coffee) and restocking
- Lodging-tax collection and filing
- Permit applications and renewals
- Owner portal, calendar access and owner stays
- Damage claims and how guest deposits or damage waivers work
4. Contracts, owner use and termination
- Term and notice. Agreements range from month-to-month with 30 or 60 days' notice to 12-month initial terms. Several companies in this directory state their terms publicly on their owner pages; others share them only in the agreement.
- Leaving. Ask about early-termination fees, what happens to bookings already on the calendar (who honors them, and who gets paid), and whether the listing, its reviews and the guest data stay with you or with the manager.
- Owner use. Check how far ahead you must block owner stays, whether owner stays carry a cleaning charge, and any blackout periods.
- Exclusivity. Most agreements make the manager the only party who can rent the home. Make sure you understand any limits on renting it yourself, or selling it, during the term.
- Insurance and liability. Ask what insurance the manager carries and what it requires you to carry, and confirm your own homeowner's policy covers short-term rental use.
5. Owner statements and money handling
Ask to see a sample owner statement before you sign. A useful statement shows each booking with the dates, the nightly revenue, each fee taken out (management, cleaning, platform, card processing, taxes), every maintenance or supply charge with the invoice attached, and the net payout. Also ask:
- How often you're paid, and how long after the guest checks out.
- Whether guest funds and taxes are held in a separate trust or escrow account (some states require this for licensed brokers).
- Who files lodging taxes, and whether you'll get year-end tax documents. For federal rules on rental income and personal use, see IRS Topic No. 415 and IRS Publication 527.
6. Permits, licenses and taxes (in general terms)
Rules are local and change often. In general, owners may need some combination of a city or county short-term rental permit or registration, a state sales or lodging-tax account, local tourist or occupancy tax filings, and HOA approval. Booking platforms collect some taxes in some places but not others. A manager can handle many of these filings, but the permit is usually in the owner's name, so the owner stays responsible.
In many states, managing rentals for other people requires a real estate broker or property management license. Ask which license the company holds and look it up with the state licensing agency.
Official starting points for some markets in this directory (each loaded on November 18, 2026):
- IRS Topic No. 415, Renting residential and vacation property
- IRS Publication 527, Residential Rental Property
- Florida Department of Revenue: sales and use tax (includes transient rentals)
- Arizona Department of Revenue: short-term lodging (TPT)
- Metro Nashville Codes: short-term rental property permits
- City of Austin: short-term rental licenses
- City of San Diego: Short-Term Residential Occupancy (STRO) license
Not legal or tax advice; confirm current rules with the agency and a qualified professional.
7. Questions to ask before you sign
- What exactly is your fee a percentage of? Can you show me a sample statement for a home like mine?
- Which costs are billed to me on top of the fee, and do you add a markup to vendor invoices?
- How many homes does each property manager or field person look after?
- Who answers guests at 2 a.m., and how fast do you respond to neighbor complaints?
- Which permits and tax accounts will you set up and file, and which stay with me?
- What's the term, the notice period and any termination fee? What happens to future bookings if I leave?
- Who owns the listing, photos and reviews?
- How are revenue projections calculated, and are they a guarantee?
- Can I talk to two or three current owners with homes like mine?
8. Red flags
- Revenue projections that are far above comparable homes, with no data behind them.
- A low headline percentage with many add-on fees that only appear in the contract.
- No written list of what's included, or no sample statement.
- Long terms with large exit fees, or the listing and reviews staying with the manager after you leave.
- Vague answers about permits, taxes, licensing or insurance.
Compare managers by market
- Asheville (10)
- Aspen & Snowmass (8)
- Austin (9)
- Big Bear Lake (10)
- Big Island (9)
- Blue Ridge (11)
- Branson (9)
- Breckenridge & Vail (13)
- Cape Cod, MV & Nantucket (16)
- Charleston Beaches (9)
- Destin & 30A (11)
- Florida Keys (8)
- Galveston (10)
- Gulf Shores & Orange Beach (12)
- Hilton Head (11)
- Hocking Hills (10)
- Jackson Hole (8)
- Kauai (10)
- LBI & Cape May (11)
- Lake Tahoe (11)
- Lake of the Ozarks (9)
- Las Vegas (10)
- Mammoth Lakes (8)
- Maui (9)
- Miami & Fort Lauderdale (11)
- Myrtle Beach (11)
- Nashville (11)
- New Orleans (9)
- North Conway (8)
- Oahu (9)
- Ocean City MD (10)
- Orlando & Kissimmee (13)
- Outer Banks (10)
- Palm Springs & Joshua Tree (10)
- Panama City Beach (10)
- Park City (11)
- Poconos (8)
- Rehoboth & Bethany (8)
- San Diego (11)
- Savannah & Tybee (10)
- Scottsdale (11)
- Sedona (12)
- Smoky Mountains (14)
- Steamboat (10)
- Stowe & Killington (10)
- Traverse City (8)
Last checked November 18, 2026. Company examples are quoted from their own public pages and are not endorsements.